Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christopher Cook's avatar

"Jefferson wrote of the affectation that some are to be saddled and ridden by those fit for ruling others."

—I learned a couple of years back that Jefferson ripped that from Col. Richard Rumbold, who used the booted and spurred metaphor in something he wrote right before his execution. By the state. For opposing the state. Naturally.

Expand full comment
Christopher Cook's avatar

"We can say that this divine principle of subsidiarity is the very spirit of gentlemanliness. A gentleman doesn’t take from the hands of his subordinates what they can do on their own. He trusts them to do what they can do—and refrains from doing it himself. A gentleman relies on his gentleman’s gentleman to look after his dinner jacket and give him a last brushstroke before he enters the dining room. (By the way, the very term for a valet, “gentleman’s gentleman,” is itself fraught with meaning and furnishes us with a precious hunch: The valet is a gentleman, too.) The contrary of this attitude of gentlemanly trust is well expressed by the German language: Besserwisserei, or “You won’t do that properly, I’ll do that for you.” As a doctrine of providence, this sort of compulsive interference is exactly wrong. God is not meddlesome."

From https://www.firstthings.com/article/2019/02/god-as-a-gentleman

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts