Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Heather B's avatar

I've read Lew Rockwell for years and used to subscribe to P J O'Rourke. (He died of lung cancer, according to Stansberry Research, who was publishing him when he died.) Have taken the quiz many times and always end up Libertarian. As for the rest, I have given up on the world realizing what is really going on. Thoughtful, as always. 👏❤️

Expand full comment
eugyppius's avatar

Yes, right-nationalism lingered on in Spain, which did not participate in World War II and has a somewhat different history as a result. But, after Franco, Spain became another liberal democracy like all the rest, and outside of Spain right-nationalism was dead in Europe, so the significance of this is a little hard for me to see.

As for Nolan and other political compasses, they seem to have a common conceptual problem, of treating 'economic' and 'personal' freedom as independent variables. In practice, 'economic freedom' is merely a subset of 'personal freedom' and regimes which intrude upon the latter will of necessity interfere with the former. Looking at the right and left quadrants of Nolan's graph, we therefore see serious problems. I do not know of any 'conservative' states that permit high degrees of economic freedom while restricting personal freedom; on the other side and in practice, 'socialist' states intervene in the personal lives of their citizens constantly. Progressive liberal governments, despite their own rhetoric, are also highly interventionist.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts